Oatmeal Cream Pie Inspired Bakery Style Cookie Recipe | Courtney's Cookies and Creations

$3.50

Oatmeal Cream Pie Bakery-Style Cookies

Soft, chewy oatmeal cookies with that rich brown sugar + molasses flavor, paired with a fluffy marshmallow cream filling that’s completely shelf-stable.

I tested multiple ways to shape these so you can get:

  • thick, textured bakery cookies

  • classic flat oatmeal cookies

  • or filled cookie cups

All three work beautifully depending on the look you want.

The cookies stay soft, the filling is light and not overly sweet, and everything holds up really well for selling and packaging.

This is a RECIPE


So happy to have you here and interested in my gourmet recipes! Please see important info below, and have a great day! <3

- This recipes measurements are in Grams and Cup's/ Tsp's.
- If you see any ingredient(s) that you can not find or do not care to include, please message me and we will find a good substitute.
- When you purchase my recipes, you agree not to resell the recipes.
- Always feel free to reach out to me any time of day, with any questions or help! <3

I hope you all find happiness and joy in my recipes! <3

Oatmeal Cream Pie Bakery-Style Cookies

Soft, chewy oatmeal cookies with that rich brown sugar + molasses flavor, paired with a fluffy marshmallow cream filling that’s completely shelf-stable.

I tested multiple ways to shape these so you can get:

  • thick, textured bakery cookies

  • classic flat oatmeal cookies

  • or filled cookie cups

All three work beautifully depending on the look you want.

The cookies stay soft, the filling is light and not overly sweet, and everything holds up really well for selling and packaging.

This is a RECIPE


So happy to have you here and interested in my gourmet recipes! Please see important info below, and have a great day! <3

- This recipes measurements are in Grams and Cup's/ Tsp's.
- If you see any ingredient(s) that you can not find or do not care to include, please message me and we will find a good substitute.
- When you purchase my recipes, you agree not to resell the recipes.
- Always feel free to reach out to me any time of day, with any questions or help! <3

I hope you all find happiness and joy in my recipes! <3